Larry Brouwer

... just my personal technology sandbox

  • About
  • Blog
  • Archives
  • Contact

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

Powered by Genesis

Troubleshooting SmarterMail incoming SMTP requests

May 12, 2010 By Larry Brouwer Leave a Comment

Today, I discovered that SmarterMail isn’t receiving emails from other hosts outside my local network. I first logged on to SmarterMail as admin. Nothing apparently wrong with the mail system. I next opened up a Command Prompt and tried to telnet to mail.larrybrouwer.com 25 and it worked fine. Next, I logged on to a remote server and again attempted to telnet to the smtp service. This time, nothing happened.

My thoughts then turned to firewall issues. So I checked to make sure that the firewall wasn’t blocking port 25. It isn’t, but just to make sure, I disabled the firewall and again tried to telnet into the email server on port 25. I’m still not able to log in.

I next suspected my D-Link DIR-655 router as the problem. I logged into the router and checked the Virtual Server settings. The the router settings look fine. I then remapped port 25 to port 80 just to see if I can get through to the web server. Re-mapping didn’t work. Now I’m really puzzled.

Still thinking that it’s a router issue (since remapping ports didn’t work), I looked at the Firewall Settings. The TCP Endpoint Filtering is set to ‘Port And Address Restricted’. I changed it to ‘Endpoint Independent’. I also enabled anti-spoof checking. I then rebooted the router. After re-logging back into the router, all of my Virtual Servers have disappeared. I re-entered them. I then attempted the telnet test to port 25 again. This still did not help the problem.

I next attempted to set up the DMZ on the DIR-655 for my web server. This should allow all traffic to flow to the web server. After re-booting, I again tried to telnet to port 25 with no success. But I am now able to telnet to port 110 (pop3).

So, by now I’m beginning to pull my hair out. What’s going on here? Well, I finally figured it out when I changed the default port for SMTP from 25 to 587. Once I did that, I was able to telnet to that port fine. So, my conclusion is that my ISP is blocking port 25 traffic. I verified this by Googling on ‘Comcast Blocked Ports’, and I got several links describing numerous ports that Comcast is blocking. The blocked ports include: 25, 68, 135-139, 445, 520, 1080, but may vary by location.

I verified this by attempting to telnet to an outside email server at port 25, and indeed it did not respond, but port 587 did respond fine.

I then went into my Comcast email account to check my messages (something I rarely do), and sure enough, there is a message “Customer Security Assurance Notice” which tells me that they’ve block port 25. I know why they did this! see my prior post here. This is a major bummer, and I read many posts left by upset Comcast customers.

I found one post that says the way to get this quickly resolved is to contact the Comcast Customer Security Assurance Center directly at (856) 317-7272 and avoid contacting the normal Comcast Internet Support channels. So I did this, and spoke to a very nice technician, and he said he would unblock the port within 15 minutes. Great news! It was actually completed within a minute of hanging up the phone with Comcast.

I then proceeded to turn on my Server’s firewall, and to configure SmarterMail back the way it was prior to all of this happening!

My next problem occurred when I attempted to send a test email from my web server to my Yahoo account, and it bounces back saying that Yahoo is not accepting messages from IP addresses on Spamhaus PBL. I did a Google search and found this article, How can I remove my IP address from the Spamhaus Database? So I went to Spamhaus and entered my IP address, and it came back with a hit on Spamhaus. I then clicked on the link to resolve the issue, and it came back stating that since I’m a Comcast residential customer, it can’t be removed from the list. Bummer!

So this means, I can receive emails, but I cannot send them. I will continue this tomorrow.

Filed Under: Daily Log Tagged With: Comcast, Port 25, SmarterMail, SMTP

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Recent Posts

  • Weaver’s Bamboo “Bambusa textilis” clumping bamboo for sale
  • configuring NTP Service on FreeNas, XenServer, and virtualized Windows Server 2012 R2 Domain Controller
  • CentOS 7 Warning: Your Magento folder does not have sufficient write permissions.
  • AOE Scheduler 1.3.0 cron issue with Magento 1.9.2.2

Tag cloud

Comcast AWStats Live Writer web.config Security TomatoCart Log Parser PST Neptune 301 Tools .NET Framework mstsc.exe PHP ASP.Net OfficeLive Silverlight MySQL iframe DIR-655 Linux Azure WordPress SBS2011 CentOS Magento SmarterMail SSL SVN Spam PrestaShop Yahoo Mail eCommerce Scanpst.exe Windows Remote Desktop BlogEngine.Net SqlServer Exchange 2010 OpenCart Outlook Connector Blogs redirect Port 25 Visual Studio SMTP